Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts

Evaluating Teachers - It's Not Rocket Science...Right?

Think Again - Welcome to the VAM Performance Formula 

- Naked Conch - Posted by Matt Gardi -  September 23, 2012

I'm all for accountability.  I also believe there are ways to evaluate almost anyone's performance.  But in the development of a teacher evaluation formula, the wizards at the State Department of Education have illustrated without a doubt why it is critical that they themselves need to be evaluated.  Psychologically evaluated.  They are straight out certifiable.  I'm not exactly sure if we can Baker Act an entire State Department, but I think it is time to try.

It might prove easier than trying to understand the formula they came up with to evaluate teacher performance.

Guest Post: Hire Higher

Why not, it's not the School Board's money?

- Naked Conch - Posted by Larry Murray - September 18, 2012
Editor's Note:  Larry Murray nails this one home.  Hey, It's great we're not hiring entrenched Bubbas at the School District, but do we really need to pay hay day wages to a new employee without testing the market with more reasonable compensation.  Also, Larry is as brevity challenged as yours truly, but hey, we're not paying for print media and killing trees, so think of it as saving natural resources!

The School District has hired a new Purchasing Agent.  That, indeed, is good news as the position has been vacant for several months.
          Not only has the District hired a new Purchasing Agent, it has hired an experienced one, taking someone previously with the Sheriff’s Department.  There will be no need for training, no learning curve to get up to speed.  Coming from the Sheriff’s Department, the new hire arrives with both general experience and a knowledge of governmental purchasing, a decided asset.  I look forward to good things coming in the purchasing area.

FCAT Follies Exposed by Insightful High School Students

Education Revolution, Scores Big
Florida Board of Education Continues to Fail to Make the Grade

- Naked Conch - Posted by Matt Gardi -  August 28, 2012

This latest winner was sent to me from Rick Roach, the School Board member from Orange County that had the fortitude to take "and fail" the FCAT (See Here.)  and says it is all about holding people accountable.  Somehow students are held accountable, as are teachers.... but the failures at the State level that can't get the quarter billion dollar boondoggle known as the FCAT together somehow escape scrutiny from the main stream media.

Fortunately, we have talented students that have a grasp on the issues (and should be running the State Board of Education) that can articulate the failure that is the FCAT, and in turn the Florida Board of Education.  Education Revolution gets a passing grade from Naked Conch with their latest production!  Enjoy!


Kinneer Tells Former Employee Recovering from Cancer to Take a Hike

Employee Who Left School District Due to Cancer Given Run Around Upon Reapplying
Kinneer Makes Up Excuse, District then Backtracks on Reason

- Naked Conch - Posted by Matt Gardi -  July 28, 2012

Former Monroe County School District Employee Rose Guieb, who was forced to resign from her IT position with the District when she was refused leave without pay as a result of her battle with and recovery from cancer was recently excluded from the applicant pool by Chief Operating Officer Michael "Give me my furlough pay!" Kinneer.

Offer to Stream Board Meeting for Free Draws Criticism

As they say...no good deed goes unpunished.

- Naked Conch - Posted by Matt Gardi -  June 30, 2012

The recent school board meeting in which our new School Superintendent was selected was steamed live over the Internet, and happily close to 2000 viewers had tuned in at some point, with as many as 187 watching at any one time.  This was conveneint, as the live broadcast on Comcast channel 78 failed.

School Board Missed the Fact Gentile's CPA Could not be Verified

Andy Griffiths -  "I also think one of us would have said, "wait a minute, why didn't you verify that"?  Seems too obvious a question for a five person board to miss. "   

Yes Andy, it does seem too obvious!

- Naked Conch - Posted by Matt Gardi -  June 23, 2012



Compounding the already ridiculous fact that School District Chief of Staff Ken Gentile is not really a CPA as he stated on his resume and as he has been attaching to his signatures, is this latest bombshell...


The School Board knew about it.  

I'm a CPA, You're a CPA, We're all CPAs...Why not?

So much for professional accreditation, right? 

I mean while we're at it, I'm an MD too.


- Naked Conch - Posted by Matt Gardi -  June 21, 2012


What was I thinking?  All caught up in this career thing, when all I needed to do was pick one.  I mean after all, it is simply some paper work and a couple of bucks, right?

Yes, you may have guessed I am referring to the latest School District scandal that School Board Candidate Larry Murray uncovered.  Apparently MCSD Chief of Staff, Ken Gentile, formerly the internal auditor, is not really a Florida CPA even though he claimed to be one on his application.  You can read about it here in the Keynoter and here in the Citizen.

How the FCAT Affected my Life

In response to the many requests to re-post the video "How the FCAT Affected my Life" in a different format, here it is embedded below.  We invite you to watch this 6 minute expose on how the FCAT is adversely affecting some of our most talented children.  It was originally provided to me by Orange County School Board member, Rick Roach. 

Students discuss the problems associated with standardized testing. This video was created by FHS Patriot Productions. Directed by Tea'a Taylor. Executive producer Cody Stanley. Copyright PTV 2012.



State Board of Education Fails with FCAT!

Miami Herald Reports Preliminary Results Indicate Only 27% Pass FCAT

No need to scratch your head on this one when you force teachers to teach for a test, then change the test and scoring methods halfway through an academic year.

- Naked Conch - Posted by Matt Gardi -  May 15, 2012
The Miami Herald is reporting today that preliminary results indicate that only 27% of fourth graders earned a passing score compared with 81% last year.  (Read about it here.)  That indicates something is wrong, but not with the children.  Rather it indicates once again that we should scrap this quarter billion dollar boondoggle pushed on us by educational wizards in Tallahassee.

We need to redirect this misallocation of funds going to the State Department of Education, and get it back down into the classroom to our aides and teachers, and let the teachers teach.  The magnitude of the wasted resources, and damage caused to our children by these lost years of FCAT folly is incomprehensible.   We need to get back to the basics and redesign the educational system from the ground up starting at the local level, where each locality is unique and faces different challenges.

It's time.

Towards that end as well, please enjoy the video below provided to me by Rick Roach, the School Board member who failed the FCAT. (You can read about it here, as it continues to maintain it's ranking as the most read post on Naked Conch!)

Watch this video to see what the FCAT is doing to some of our most talented kids!

Thanks again to Rick Roach for his efforts!



Save the Teachers! - Divest from Fannie Mae

What would you rather invest in, our kids, or a failed quasi-federal boondoggle?
- Naked Conch - Posted by Matt Gardi -  May 10, 2012
Would you prefer to invest in our kids and teachers, or invest in a failed banker led company in conservatorship, whose assets are comprised primarily of the most toxic mortgage backed securities, whose liability covers an ocean of underwater mortgages, and who could not even be in operation if not for billions in bailouts?

Well you, my dear friends, are increasingly investing in the latter, while sticking it to the teachers and our children.

That's right, according to a recent report (See Here) I obtained from the Clerk's Office, the County, (you and I) are invested in Fannie Mae for close to $50 MILLION Dollars.  In fact, over half of our County investments totaling close to $130 Million bucks are tied up in GSEs, or "Government Sponsored Enterprises," private companies backed by our tax dollars.  (That means, they get the profits, we get the losses.)  In fact, we are seemingly increasing the percentage of our portfolio placed with GSEs.

But meanwhile, back at the School District, we are facing a $6 million dollar shortfall and teacher layoffs.  Recently School Board member Andy Griffiths has been discussing a huge reduction in bond payments that will free up close to $1 Million per month of capital outlays in October of 2015.  But no one, including Andy, has offered any type of stopgap measure to get us from here to there in the interim...aside from the novel idea of a tax increase, of course.

So, if you think about it, dollars we HAVE, are invested in failed companies that need dollars we DON'T HAVE to operate. (Essentially federal debt we are saddling our children with.)  In the meantime, resources we allocate to those very children being saddling with federal debt are being cut back.  We have essentially created student loans for grade school kids, while providing them with less of an education.  Seems like we could do better if we put the 1st graders in charge.

Here is my solution.  We divest from Fannie Mae, and use some of that money to refinance the School's bonded indebtedness.  We extend the terms of the debt, reducing the cost of interest to the school system while reducing their payments, and actually allow for an INCREASE in the rate of return on the County investment as opposed to what Fannie Mae offers.  As voters, we allow for more of the millage to be redirected from capital to operational so that we can fund the current operating shortfall.

This would not cost the taxpayers anything, replenish our fund balance, and eliminate the need to layoff teachers.

However, this is not intended to let the administration and school board off the hook for their failed leadership.  It's time to "Right Size" admin.  That's right, it's great that we can pay these wizards boatloads of cash when times are rosy, but when the tide goes out, their boats should sink first!

We need to cap all administrative pay at $90,000, and eliminate all pay and benefits to the school board until the ship is righted.  If these wizards can't accept this reduction for the good of our children, then let them leave, and leave quickly.  There will be countless talented individuals from throughout our community that will step up to the plate out of dedication to the kids and our community, a type of motivation that is needed now more than ever.  We no longer need placeholders, we need people that perform.

We can talk about potential teacher reductions, or teacher pay cuts, but with the mindset of whether or not it is truly feasible or warranted.  But certainly not in the context that Superintendent Jara does, suggesting he is only NOW "right sizing," coincidentally when we have a $6 Million dollar shortfall, and not last year when he suggested we had "cut to the bone."

Before we cut teachers or their pay, we must remember we already did last year.  Those furlough days you heard about were simply a way for the district to say, "You don't get paid for Holidays anymore."  That came right out of teachers' paychecks.  Also, if we need to talk about pay cuts for teachers, we need to talk disproportionately about pay cuts for admin.  Whether it's a bigger drop in the bucket or not, administrators need to feel a greater pain from their own failed leadership!







Andy Griffiths Draws Challengers

Not Just One, But TWO!

BREAKING NEWS - April 14, 2012
According to the Monroe County Supervisor of Elections website, School Board member Andy Griffiths has drawn two challengers to the District 2 School Board Race.  This is fantastic, as we at Naked Conch have always advocated for contested races.


Howard Hubbard and Yvette Mira-Talbott have thrown their hats in the ring to challenge long time board member Andy Griffiths.  We thank Howard and Yvette for giving the voters a choice.  Hopefully, we will see all of them at the Hometown PAC elections forum this Monday evening, April 16 at Salute restaurant in Key West at 6PM!  Hopefully we will see you there as well!






Superintendent Unable to View Line Item Budget

Could that be the reason we bounce from one financial crisis to another?  Ya Think?
- Naked Conch - Posted by Matt Gardi -  April 10, 2012


School Superintendent Jesus Jara took his dog and pony show to the Sugarloaf School yesterday evening for the second of five presentations to discuss the current fiscal year's budget challenges. After a powerpoint presentation in which he outlined previous years' budget reductions, discussed the habit of depleting reserves over the last few years, and offered the expected solution of eliminating FORTY teachers, he then turned the discussion over to the approximately sixty people in attendance.


What ensued in this quest for suggestions from the public could only be described as searching for a needle in a haystack...blindfolded. Let me tell you, finding needles by grasping at straws makes their discovery a bit...shall we say...painful. For instance, when accused of not having to pay for health insurance, Jara was quick to respond that he pays his own, however, there are still a few individuals in the system that don't contribute at all. When asked to eliminate supplemental pay for administrators, Jara suggested that they had done so... well except in a few small instances. When asked to reduce salaries in administration, Jara suggested that even reducing the pay of the top forty-four administrators would not solve the budget dilemma.


What seemed lost in the discussion to me was a clear explanation of how exactly we are spending our money. When challenged to explain how the money spent last year grew from an approved $78 million, to an actual $83 Million, Jara's response was a bit vague and confusing. Which begged the question, why isn't the public presented with a line-item budget, which would include last year's approved, last year's actual, and this year's proposed line items? That way, thousands of eyes could pour over the details, and perhaps those members of the public wishing to contribute ideas or suggestions for cost savings, could do so with all the information in front of them. Why can't we see exactly what Superintendent Jara looks at when he develops his proposed budget?


Apparently we can, and we do.


As shocking as it may seem, what is provided to the public is all that our School Superintendent has to look at as well. There is no comprehensive, collective line item budget or financial software that is available even to our School Administrators.


A few weeks ago I had a discussion with School Board Member Rob Smith-Martin whereby he expressed his challenges to obtain financial information. Last night I asked School Board Member Andy Griffiths if he could obtain a line item budget, and he said that he could, made a gesture that it is a huge stack of paper, and suggested that it wasn't easy to obtain.


So I asked the question to Superintendent Jara, why can't the public view a line item budget online, referencing as an example the ability to possibly see which administrator was being payed supplemental pay. Jara was quick to suggest he could and would have supplemental pay posted online in the morning. But I pressed on, I wasn't looking for an isolated response to an item found as a result of pulling my bloodied hand out of the haystack, I want to easily peruse the budget and see all the needles without having to discover them by sense of touch.


Again, Jara was quick to suggest that that is all available as well, and quickly pulled up what would be used at an upcoming School Board Budget workshop. However, what he displayed was still fairly generalized categories, and I pressed him to show me from the list a few examples such as who is getting supplemental pay, and how much a specific software costs. He admitted that he couldn't but suggested that I could find the technology budget on line.


I then stated that what I really wanted to see was exactly what Jesus Jara is able to review when he makes his proposals, I don't want to be forced to hunt and peck for information in a thousand different places, some of which I may or may not know exist. That's when I was given the bombshell. That is the ONLY way our school financial information is available, even to administrators. Jara suggested there was not an existing comprehensive budget system or document, and that creating one would cost $500,000, and we simply don't have the money.


That is like saying, "Hey, there isn't a steering wheel in this car, but we can just keep pressure on this accelerator thingy and we'll get someplace."  Jara ultimately admitted that the $500,000 estimated cost associated with development of a system to consolidate a comprehensive budget would come from capital funding, a funding source that wouldn't strain the general fund annual budget, but appeared to still throw his hands up in the air as if it was impractical.


As I was leaving, a couple of members of the school audit and finance committee suggested that I should keep pressing for such a solution, as it is something that has frustrated them as well.


As a candidate for Clerk of Courts, I have said that transparency is a key element of my campaign. Placing agency line item budgets on line, available to public scrutiny, is one of the ways I would strive to develop that atmosphere of transparency. While I realize the Clerk's Office has no dominion over the School system, perhaps that is something that School Administrators should consider implementing as well, especially if they are taking the dog and pony show on the road seeking public input.